A Study on Effectiveness of Structured
Teaching program on Road Safety Measures among Primary School Children in
Selected School at Bangalore
Tintu Annie Mathew*
Assistant Professor, NIMS College of Nursing, Bhubaneswar, Orissa
*Corresponding Author Email: tmmarangattu168@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
An experimental study with two groups pre test and post test
design was undertaken in selected school in Bangalore, Karnataka to assess the
effectiveness of structured teaching program on road safety measures among primary school
children. Total numbers of 100 primary school children were selected to assess
the effectiveness of structured teaching program regarding road safety
measures, the level of knowledge regarding road safety measures before and after structured
teaching program and also to study the association between socio demographic
variables and level of knowledge in experimental and control group.
In pretest, 2% of children had inadequate knowledge, 98% had
moderately adequate and none of had adequate knowledge. In posttest, none of
had inadequate knowledge, 4% had moderately adequate and 96% had adequate
knowledge for experimental group. Same like for control group in pretest, 18% of
children had inadequate knowledge, 82% had moderately adequate and none of had
adequate knowledge .In posttest 4% of children had inadequate knowledge, 94%
had moderately adequate and 2%had adequate knowledge. This indicates that
experimental group has more knowledge than the control group after
administration of structured teaching program
The result shows that the structured program was highly effective
as the P value is 0.000 and the unpaired T value is 15.73. The mean difference
of the experimental group (14.2) is higher than the mean difference of the
control group (3.48). It indicates that the experimental group has more
knowledge than the control group after administering structured teaching
program.
There is a significant relationship between the level of knowledge
and the socio demographic variables such as mother’s educational status,
father’s educational status and religion for control group. In experimental
group there is significant relationship between the level of knowledge and the
socio demographic variables such as mother’s educational status and father’s
educational status.
KEY
WORDS: Effectiveness,
Structured Teaching programme, Road safety, Primary
school children
NEED FOR STUDY:
Every day
as many as one lakh forty thousand people are injured
on the world’s roads. More than three thousand people die and some fifteen are
disabled for life. Each of those people has a network of family, friends,
neighbors, colleagues or classmates who are also affected emotionally
otherwise.
Families struggle with poverty when they
lost bread winner or have the added expense of caring for disabled family
members.
According to World Health Organization,
nearly 1.18 million people lost their lives every year due to road accidents.
Almost 18000 young people are injured in Australia roads every year. In
Australia 958 persons killed in the year of 2001, 958 persons killed in the
year of 2002 and 931 persons killed in the year of 2003.
Fifteen children under the age of 15 lost
their lives and 1079 were injured in Norwegian Traffic accidents in 2002, and
increase of 8 children killed and 122 children injured compared 2001.The number
of road accidents registered during the year of 2007 was 20,519 against 20,242
in the preceding year. Among these accidents, majority 18,329 were non-injury,
133 fatal injury, 403 serious injury and 1,654 slight injuries compared to 2006
accidents causing casualties went up by 12.5 percent, non-injury by 0.2
percent, fatal injury by 0.9 percent,
serious injury by 36 percent and slight injuries by 8.2 percent. The number of
children road traffic fatalities increased when compared with 2006. On average, twenty children have died each
year during 2000.
Current figures are alarming enough. If
they continue by 2020, the number of people killed and disabled every day on
the world’s roads will have grown by more than 60 percent making road traffic
injuries a leading contributor to the global burden of disease and injury.
Today, they account for 90 percent of the deaths and disabilities resulting
from road traffic injuries. Soon, that will rise to 95 percent. By taking
action now and by working together, we can reverse the current trends and save
million of adults and children from death and disability between now and 2020
and many millions more people in the years beyond.
Rapid population growth, industrialization and
an increase in road vehicle has lead to predictions that by 2020 global death
rate from road traffic accidents will rise by 67 percent. This increasing
morbidity and mortality rate, particularly for those of working age, promises
devastating consequences for the economic growth of low –income countries.
In Bangalore city, 628 people died in 2000
and 659 were killed in 2001 nearly 9000 people have been injured in accidents
in 2002, while the number of injured in the last two years was around 84,000
and 900 death in 2004, seven hundred and four (704) people died in 2005. Nearly
7000 persons died in road accidents annually in Karnataka and the numbers
alarmingly increasing.
A
study conducted on “tackling children’s road safety through educational programme” to evaluate the effectiveness of a video
assisted teaching to the knowledge of children’s road safety. The study revealed video assisted teaching
had an impact of either children’s knowledge or parent’s awareness of
pedestrian skills when used in a standard home based fashion. The sample size
was 120 families, all of whom had children of 5 years of age. Half the families
received videos at the beginning of the study, while the other half serves as a
control group against which to measure changing treatment group. However, the
conclusion was when videos are used in a casual fashion; they had an
educational impact on either parents or children.
Now - a-days only a few children walk to
school compared to previous generation. This is because parents feel safe to
drive their children to school resulting in poor road crossing skills among
children. Hence, children should be given awareness regarding road safety.
There is less number of research studies done on knowledge of primary school
children regarding road safety measures.
By watching school children after their
school timings, walking as they like and getting shouting by vehicle drivers,
passers-by, vendors and house-wives, the
researcher felt the need to educate the children regarding road safety
measures. The structured teaching programme would
help children prevent such accidents and avoid behaviors that lead to accidents
such as stop, look and listen, pedestrians signs, bus safety, pedestrian’s
safely, traffic light meanings etc.
The purpose this study was assessing the
existing level of knowledge of primary school children regarding road safety
measures and providing structured teaching programme
regarding road safety measures to enhance their knowledge level to prevent road
traffic accidents.
OBJECTIVES:
1. To assess the level of knowledge among
primary school children regarding road safety measures before and after
structured teaching program.
2. To determine the effectiveness of
structured teaching program.
3. To find out the association between socio
demographic variables and level of knowledge.
HYPOTHESIS:
H1: There is
a significant difference in the level of knowledge among primary school
children regarding
road safety measures before and after structured teaching
program.
H2: There is
a significance difference in the post knowledge level of primary school
children.
H3: There is
a significant association between socio demographic variables and level of
knowledge in both experimental group and control group.
RESULTS:
Experimental
group:
In pretest, 2% of children had inadequate
knowledge, 98% had moderately adequate and none of had adequate knowledge. In
posttest, none of had inadequate knowledge, 4% had moderately adequate and 96%
had adequate knowledge.
Control
group:
In pretest, 18% of children had inadequate
knowledge, 82% had moderately adequate and none of had adequate knowledge .In
posttest 4% of children had inadequate knowledge, 94% had moderately adequate
and 2%had adequate knowledge. This indicates that experimental group has more
knowledge than the control group after administration of structured teaching
program
The finding of the study are supported with
a similar study conducted on assess the
level of knowledge among primary school children regarding road safety measures
before and after structured teaching program. This study result shows that 3%
of children had inadequate knowledge, 97% had moderately adequate, none of had
inadequate knowledge in experimental group before structured teaching program
and after structured teaching program 6%
of children had moderately adequate knowledge, 94% had adequate knowledge and
non of had inadequate knowledge. In control group pretest, 10% of children had
inadequate knowledge, 90% had moderately adequate and none of had adequate
knowledge.
In posttest 3% of children had inadequate
knowledge, 96% had moderately adequate and 1%had adequate knowledge. This
indicates that experimental group has more knowledge than the control group
after administration of structured teaching program.
After collecting the data from all the 100
samples the data was analyzed for the effectiveness of the structured teaching
program by using a unpaired‘t’ test . The result
shows that the structured program was highly effective as the P value is 0.000
and the unpaired T value is 15.73. The mean difference of the experimental
group (14.2) is higher than the mean difference of the control group (3.48). It
indicates that the experimental group has more knowledge than the control group
after administering structured teaching programme.
The finding of the study is supported with
a similar study conducted on the effectiveness of structured teaching program
on road safety measures among school children in Malaysia. The data were
analyzed using unpaired‘t’ test. The result shows
that the structured program was highly effective as the P value is 0.000 and
the unpaired T value is 15.73. The mean difference of the experimental group
(16.2) is higher than the mean difference of the control group (2.4). It
indicates that the experimental group has more knowledge than the control group
after administering structured teaching program.35
The association between the socio
demographical variables and the level of knowledge was done using chi square
formula. In experimental group there is
a significant relationship between the level of knowledge and the socio
demographic variables such as mother’s educational status, father’s educational
status and religion. There is no significance relationship between the level of
knowledge and socio demographic variables such as age gender, children
educational status, parents occupation, type of family, dietary pattern, number
of children in the family, birth order of the child, number of older siblings,
previous information and source of information.
In control group
there is a significant relationship between the level of knowledge and the
socio demographic variables such as mother’s educational status and father’s
educational status. There is no significance relationship between the level of
knowledge and socio demographic variables such as age gender, children
educational status, parent’s occupation, type of family, religion, dietary
pattern, number of children in the family, birth order of the child, number of
older siblings, previous information and source of information.
Fig.1
Level of knowledge among primary school children between experimental and
control group before and after structured teaching program
Fig.2
Effectiveness of structured teaching program
DISCUSSION:
The result shows that the structured
program was highly effective as the P value is 0.000 and the unpaired T value
is 15.73. The mean difference of the experimental group (14.2) is higher than
the mean difference of the control group (3.48). It indicates that the
experimental group has more knowledge than the control group after
administering structured teaching program.
There is a significant relationship between the level of knowledge and
the socio demographic variables such as mother’s educational status, father’s
educational status and religion for control group. In experimental group there
is significant relationship between the level of knowledge and the socio
demographic variables such as mother’s educational status and father’s
educational status.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Based on the findings of the study the
following recommendations are stated:
·
A
comparative study can be carried out to find out the knowledge of primary
school children in urban and rural areas regarding road safety measures.
·
Similar
study can be undertaken with a large sample to generalize the findings.
·
A
similar study can be carried out to find out the level of knowledge among
teachers regarding road safety measures in urban rural area.
REFERENCES:
1.
Diana
Joseph. Causes of accident. Buzzle.Com. Intelligent life in the web.10-3.
2.
Ahimed M.
Meaning of road traffic accidents. Publisher Parts Hanger. European Journal of
Epidemiology. 2004 March; Volume (13): 35-3
3.
Parts
Hanger. Common causes of accidents in children. Journal of community health
nursing. 2002. April; Volume (XXX): 412-5.
4.
Swamy
H.M., Puri S.
Road safety awareness and practice among school children of Chandigarh.
Indian Journal of Community Medicine.2006September; Volume (31): 123-4.
5.
Rati T.
Risk factors for road traffic accidents. Abstracts of paper present on the 13th
International conference on safe community. Republished by Prague, Czech.2004
June; Volume (21): 44 -5
6.
John
D. Study on evaluate the long term severely injured patients. Journal of
academic child adolescent psychiatry. Published by Indian scenario Neurology
Research. 2003 January; Volume (11): 26-2
7.
Dr.
Lee J. Road safety is no accident .World Health Day Theme 2004. The Nursing
Journal of India 2004 April; Vol. XCV (4): 74-2.
8.
Juane W.Road safety no accident. Published by pan American Health
Organization. WHO 202. 974-10
9.
Viju B. kartikage. Highway accidents bleed insurance cos. The time
of India I-2
10. Zeedyk M.S. Tackling children road safety through
educational program. Oxford Journal. Health education research. Volume 18.
November 4. 493-505
11. Moses.M. Nursing theories. Nursing Research. 2007
mar 5;45(6):78-91.
12. Sundar T. Prevalence rate of road traffic
accidents in India (2008 to 2009). Published by road transport road traffic
accidents statistics. 2009 January; 4-5.
13. Jgmom. How to teach children pedestrian safety
rules. Kids and safety 2008 March; Volume (6): 3- 2.
14. Shahies MA. A study on road side accident in
Faisalabad city. Indian journal of community medicine. March 2006. Vol. XXIX
(1). 18-4
15. Giogi Rossi, Farchis, Chini F, Camilloni L, Borgia P, Guasticchi. Road traffic injuries in Lazio, Italy: a
descriptive analysis from an emergency department- based surveillance system.
Annual emergency medicine 2005 Aug; Volume (46): 152-7
16. Landolt .MA, Voirath M, Gnehm HE, Sennhauses FH.
Predicting post traumatic stress symptoms in children after Road Traffic
Accidents. Journal of Academic child Adolescent Psychiatry. 2005 December;
Volume (12): 1276- 9.
17. Dana Dona R, Mishra.
Death due to road traffic crashes in Hyderabad city in India; need for
strengthening surveillance. National medical journal of India 2004 March-
April; Volume (17): 74-79.
18. Sreenivasa D.K. Gautham
Roy. Epidemiological study of Road Traffic Accident cases. A study from South
India. Indian Journal of Community Medicine 2004 Jan- March; Vol. XXIX: 20-4.
19. Guraraj G. Alcohol and road traffic injuries in
South Asia: challenges for prevention. Journal of Physicians surgery 2004
December; Volume (14); 713-6
20. Muralidhar V, Roy N. Measuring trauma outcomes in
India: an analysis based on TRISs methodology in a Mumbai university hospital.
2004 April; Volume (4): 386-9.
21. Mosby.N.A study conducted on All Terrain Vehicle
(ATV).Journal of community medicine 2004 March; Volume (24): 16-3..
22. Timperio A, Crawford D, Telford A, Salmon J.
Perception about the local neighborhood and walking and cycling among children.
Journal of Preventive Medicine 2004 Jan; Volume (38): 39- 6.
23. Hilal O. Traffic Accidents in Turkey. Abstracts
of papers presented on the 13th international conference on safe
Communities; Prague, Czech Republic 2004 June; 46-5.
24. .Rathapan C, Ratipoen T. The patterns of Traffic Safety in Thailand. In:
Svanstrom L; Bolvesslav J; Grivanam; editors. Sustainability within safe Communities.
Abstracts of papers presented on the 13th international conference
on safe Communities 2004June; .44-4.
25. Harry H, Vaganay
M. Traffic exposure of children. In:
Svanstrom L; Bolvesslav J; Grivanam; editors. Sustainability within safe Communities.
Abstracts of papers presented on the 13th international conference
on Safe Communities 2004 September; 56-6.
26. Edgar M,
Maria- Isabel G, Andra A. Counter measures to prevent traffic
injuries in Cali- Colombia. In: S vanstrom L; 2004
June 45-5.
27. Romao F, Nizamo H, Mapase D, Rafico MM, Jose J, et
al. Road Traffic Injuries In Mozambique. Injury control safe promotion 2003 March-
January; Volume (10): 63-67.
28. Afukar FH,
Antwi P, Ofosu-A. Pattern of
road traffic injuries in Ghana: implications for control. Injury control safe
promotion 2003 March- January; Volume (1-2): 69-76.
29. Tripathy M. Epidemiology of traumatic brain
injuries: Indian scenario Neurology Research 2002 January; Volume (24): 266-74.
30. Aileron ME. Head injury victims in fatal
road traffic accidents in Delhi. Journal of community medicine2002 April;
Volume (42): 34-15.
31. Lam LT. Parental risk perception of
childhood pedestrian road safety: a cross cultural comparison. Journal of
safety Research 2005 November; Volume 36(2): 181-7.
32. Corden TE, Tripathy, Kather ML. The role of health care professional in bicycle
safety. WM Journal 2005 Feb; Volume 104 (2): 35-8.
33. Welss J, Okum M, Quacy N. Predicting bicycle helmet stage of change among
middle school, high school and college cyclists from demographic variables.
Journal of Pediatrics 2004 Sep; Volume145 (3): 360- 4.
34. Lyn, V, Allan Q, Bongi
D. Promoting Road safety through community education program. An International
study-South Africa’s case study report. In: Svanstrom
L; Bolveslav J; Grivna M;
Editors. Sustainability within safe communities. Abstracts of papers presented on the 13th
International conference on safe communities; 2004 June: 45-10.
35. Kulanthan S, Nasir MT,
Ahmad H, Musa AH, Radian US. The effectiveness structured teaching program on
road safety measures among school children in Malaysia. Journal of community
medicine 2004June;47 12.
36. Zabibi Z, Petter K.
Choosing a safe place to cross the road: the relationship between attention
and identification of a safe and
dangerous road crossing sites, Child
Health Care development 2003 July; Volume 29(4): 237-44.
37. Anne D. Junior Road Safety Officers, in: Svanstrom L; Bolvesslav J; Grivanam; editors. Sustainability within safe Communities
2004 October; Volume34 (7): 45-12.
38. Langly JD, Dow N, Slephensens,
Kypri. Missing Cyclists. Injury prevention 2003
December; Volume 9(4): 376-37.
39. Balati M. A study was conducted on “assessing the
validity of road safety education studies by analyzing causal chain”. Journal
of community medicine 2002 July; Volume (4) 234- 23.
40. Pravanth J. A study on assess the level of
knowledge among school children regarding road safety. Journal community
medicine 2004 December; Volume (34): 35-12.
Received on 14.08.2013 Modified on 20.02.2014
Accepted on 04.03.2014 ©
A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Nur. Edu. & Research 4(2): April- June 2014; Page 207-211